The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Blu-ray/DVD Review

The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug DVD/Blu-Ray

A review by

Lady Anglophile



“If this is to end in fire…then we will all burn together”

And that pretty much sums up Thorin Oakenshield’s determination to achieve his goal of re-entering the Lonely Mountain and taking back what is rightfully his….no matter what the cost. And in The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug we begin to get a glimpse of exactly what that cost might be.

In the long awaited DVD/Blu-Ray release of Peter Jackson’s second installment in a trilogy of films adapted from J.R.R. Tokien’s enduring novel, “The Hobbit”, the Dwarves are back along with everyone’s favorite Hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, (played to perfection by Sherlock’s Martin Freeman) and the legendary Sir Ian McKellen as Gandalf the Grey, as they continue in their epic quest to reclaim the lost Dwarf Kingdom of Erebor from Smaug, the ferocious fire-breathing dragon (voiced by the deliciously dangerous tone’s of Benedict Cumberbatch) who holds possession of all the gold including the king’s stone, the Arkenstone, which will put the heir apparent, Oakenshield, (gloriously played by Richard Armitage) back on the throne where he belongs! (Whew! Got that?) After all it’s been nearly 200 years since his homeland was ravaged and captured by Smaug and the Dwarves were either slain or sent wandering homeless…why shouldn’t Thorin be hell-bent on taking back Erebor? As he says in the film, “I have the only right.”

It might be refreshing to know (or not) that, unlike millions of loyal Tolkien aficionados, I did not grow up reading The Hobbit/Lord of the Rings books and therefore did not have a pre-conceived, dogmatic vision of how the books should be represented up on the big screen. As far as I was concerned, Peter Jackson was free to do with the story as he wished…and apparently, much to many a Tolkein fan’s chagrin, that’s exactly what he did. Bringing back Orlando Bloom in the role of Legolas, who does not appear in The Hobbit book, was one of them. But as Jackson explains, “He’s Thranduil’s son, and Thranduil is one of the characters in The Hobbit, and because elves are immortal it makes sense Legolas would be part of the sequence in the Woodland Realm.”  Sounds good to me. Listen the man is an Academy Award winning director, who am I to disagree? And while he’s at it let’s toss in a potential love interest for Legolas in the form of Tauriel, (played by Lost’s beautiful Evangeline Lilly) the head of the Mirkwood Elven Guard, (think Tinker Bell on steroids) who spends a great portion of the film either saving or flirting with, Thorin’s nephew, Kili (played by the gorgeous Aidan Turner.) Hey, I’d flirt too.


Okay, let me get something off my chest right now: in my next life I want to come back as Evangeline Lily. The woman got to spend six seasons frolicking on a beach in Hawaii shooting ABC’s Lost, looking all sexy and windblown while wielding a gun, with two of the world’s sexiest guys (“Sawyer” and “Jack”) vying for her affection. CUT TO: New Zealand, working with ‘Directing God’ Jackson, where she now gets to wield a bow and arrow, wear a cute little figure-hugging Elf costume (I’m getting one for Halloween), and flirt with Orlando Bloom and Aidan Turner. JUMP CUT TO: The Hobbit world press tour where, as the only female in a testosterone driven film, she gets to shine in gorgeous designer gowns and have Richard Armitage asking her for drinks in Dwarvish….which I’m pretty sure he learned just to impress her!  Yep, I wanna come back as Evangeline Lily…..


But I digress.

Much of Desolation of Smaug’s forward motion is action-packed with our merry band of determined dwarves encountering various obstacles on the perilous road to Erebor. A run in with skin-changer Beorn (played by Swedish actor Mikael Persbrandt), a nasty bit with spiders in the forests of Mirkwood (I’ve watched it twice, now I just hit the fast forward button…), being captured by the Wood-elves led by the villainous King Thranduil (the perfectly cast Lee Pace), and my favorite scene featuring what should become the next big theme-park ride…the barrel escape! The Dwarves go white water rapids racing in wine barrels to escape Thranduil’s dungeons! (Thorin’s long wet, rock-star-like locks flinging in the wind, mind you!)


All the while the great orc, Azog the Defiler, continues on his vengeful quest of destroying Thorin. He’s like a giant gnat that won’t go away. The Dwarves have enough blockade running to do on their way to Erebor without having to deal with this nasty beast every 20minutes.  This all leads them to their encounter with Bard the Bowman (played with heart by Luke Evans), their journey to Lake-Town where we see more of Thorin’s desperation revealed as he is willing to leave behind his ailing nephew Kili suffering from a poison-filled arrow wound and finally…the moment we’ve all been waiting for, the arrival at the Lonely Mountain where upon the last light of Durin’s day will reveal a key-hole where they might insert the key that will finally welcome them home!

But what awaits them inside is what Cumberbatch fans have been waiting two films for. The Hobbit must face Smaug the Magnificent and, like a needle in a haystack, find the Arkenstone! Cumberbatch’s rich Alan Rickman-esque voice does not disappoint. I actually think I applauded when I first heard it provoking strange looks from my fellow theatre-goers. But I was like a kid in a Sherlock gift shop watching Martin Freeman’s Hobbit and Cumberbatch’s Smaug face-off!  Even with Cumberbatch relegated to solitary confinement doing mo-cap in a soundstage somewhere, you could STILL see and feel the chemistry between these two fantastic actors.



But it’s Richard Armitage’s towering and layered performance as Thorin Oakenshield that steals the show for me.


If Oscars are handed out to actors who lose themselves so significantly, and unrecognizably in a role, then Armitage should be making room for one on his mantle piece. Having interviewed Armitage, I can tell you first hand that you can not detect even one trace of the would-be dwarf king in him. Not in looks, in tone of voice or in mannerisms. Well, you might say, that’s an actor’s job isn’t it? To become someone else, so completely unrecognizable from who they actually are. Yes it is. But how often do we actually see that it today’s leading men? Not often. When I’m watching Oakenshield’s journey towards an all consuming desperation and greed not once do I think that’s the same actor who once played John Thorton in Elizabeth Gaskell’s period drama, “North and South”. In fact, I do not think I’m watching an actor at all.. and it has nothing to do with the elaborate prosthetics  Amitage had to wear while making the film. It’s what Shakespeare was talking about in Hamlet’s speech to the players when he urged them to create the illusion of reality by holding the mirror up to nature.

“Speak the speech I pray you as I pronounce it to you, trippingly on the tongue; but if you mouth it as many of your players do I had as lief the town-crier spoke my lines.”

I think I’m fairly safe in saying that Peter Jackson and Producer/Co-Writer Philippa Boyens do not believe the town crier is spoke any of Thorin’s lines. And if you know the book (and I do now because I read the Cliff Notes) you know what lies ahead for Oakenshield.

Armitage, get your speech ready!


If you don’t already own a Blu-ray player, buy one. It’s worth it to see Jackson’s film in all its glory. From beginning to end the edge of your seat action never stops but it does not do so at the expense of storytelling such as with Bard and his family, which gives us a touch of real life back story to this fantastic adventure.

BardFamily BardSon

You’ll also enjoy the Special Features especially the “day in the life of” featurette where Jackson invites you onto the set to experience what life was like for the cast and crew of The Hobbit films. You will walk away with a great sense of appreciation and respect for all the hundreds of talented unseen heroes (1100 crew!) behind the camera. These are the people who magically bring Tolkein’s world to life and made this film happen! But their life in New Zealand was more than that. This was like the greatest job-relocation gig in history. Only you weren’t packing the wife and kids up and moving to boring East BumbleBerry, USA. These people moved a half a world away (well, many of them were locals) for the better part of two years and became one big family. Enjoying school-like lunchtime breaks where they played ‘9-ball’ at recess, live-entertainment during mealtimes, Weiners Wacky Wheel of Wonders where crew spun a giant wheel to win prizes like a weekends away or cash! Made “Dwarfericise” videos and dwarf calendars. Arts and Crafts and Teatime! I want to go to Peter Jackson Camp too!


One thing you can see for sure is this experience changed their lives. Even Luke Evans said they formed such close bonds that when it was time to go back to reality, he said, “not sure I’m ready for that.”  No wonder Armitage nearly moved to New Zealand permanently. I’m sure this was a unique experience that they’ll all remember for the rest of their careers and lives.


“You’re not the same hobbit that left the shire…”, says Gandalf to Bilbo Baggins.  I think we are, none of us, the same. We’re all changed after experiencing The Hobbit films. Cast, crew and audience alike. And even though I didn’t read the Tolkien books,  I’ve become such a fan of the Tolkein/Jackson combo that I’m got my Elvish ears ready to camp out for my local midnight showing of The Hobbit: There and Back Again this December!

Own “THE HOBBIT: THE DESOLATION OF SMAUG” Limited Collector’s Edition Blu-ray 3D Combo Pack, Blu-ray 3D Combo pack, Blu-ray Combo pack, 2-disc DVD special edition, and Digital HD on 4/8


Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, stars Martin Freeman, Richard Armitage, Ian McKellen, Benedict Cumberbatch, Evangeline Lilly, Lee Pace, Luke Evans, Stephen Fry, Ken Stott, James Nesbitt and Orlando Bloom.

Thank you to Warner Bros. Pictures and Warner Bros. Home Entertainment for providing us with copies to giveaway to your loyal Hobbit fans!

Hobbit Fans: There is STILL time to WIN The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Blu-ray Combo Pack PLUS the AUTOGRAPHED The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey signed by RICHARD ARMITAGE! Leave your comment on the video below!  See you all at The Hobbit: There and Back Again!






This entry was posted in Lady Anglophile Reviews & Other Bits and Bobs and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Blu-ray/DVD Review

  1. What a great review! Thanks a lot!
    (And yes, I’d love to win the DVD/BluRays touched by Thorin Himself! 🙂 )

  2. Diana S. Long says:

    Great review, I remember years ago the animated film the Hobbit, this is so much better!

  3. Maria says:

    Hi, I would love to win the DVDs!! Love the Hobbit movies!! Thank you for all the great work that you do!!

  4. Silvia says:

    I’ve always been a Tolkien enthusiasts. I read The Lord of the Rings some 10-12 times, The Hobbit only a couple but The Silmarillion is my real favourite book; said that, I am glad to state that I am not dogmatic at all about the adaptations of his works to the big screen. I thoroughly enjoyed Mr. Jackson’s works because I’ve always thought that the shifts, the changes and additions were all aimed at keeping the story flowing and entertaining. Prof. Tolkien was very specific in his descriptions and explanations, it is simply impossible to put his work on screen without some “shortcuts” and these shortcuts were taken by Jackson to perfection. I’m a distant reader, from a faraway Country (Italy) and not an English native speaker but – gosh – this review made me go back to Mirkwood with goose bumps! Thanks for your wonderful work. Hugs.

  5. Elisabeth says:

    Wow! Great review! Now I can´t wait any longer to get the Blu-ray ❤ 🙂

  6. Dorothy says:

    Awesome flowing review with a healthy dose of personality!! I agree with you in that these movies are a great piece of art where all things, story, actors come together to make a complete story that is not static but moving and evolving. I feel as if the characters grow not only in complexity but there is the ‘illusion of physical growth’…the dwarfs are no more shorter than the elves. Every character has his own dimension and in turn gives dimension to the others. There is a continuum in the characters each giving his/her own input to the whole story. That is without one there is no other and interestingly besides the real bad guys there is a conglomeration of heroes rather than only one. I agree that Mr. Armitage here has given lots and lots. I imagine it might have been physically and emotionally absorbing to play such a part! He got adsorbed in Thorin with emotions of great responsibility, pride, anger, loneliness, protection, leadership and many more showing through strongly throughout and growing even….an awesome job!! Hats off to Mr. Jackson for putting this up together in such a way as to enable anticipation to grow from movie to movie without any hint of boredom…mammoth job…and to make this so picture perfect!!! Would go on forever!!! Thanks again Lady Anglophile!!!

  7. Solveig says:

    You did a terrific job – thank you for that great review, Lady Anglophile!
    (And of course I´d like to win that DVD!)

  8. Mary Gillmarten says:

    Wonderful review! I agree with you — hats off to Mr. Jackson! What an incredible visionary he has turned out to be. I was touched by the verbatim bits from the books and then the modifications for the dramatic effect of film. Your review has given full credit where full credit is due.

  9. Martha says:

    A fabulous review Marlise! I was unable to see the film in the theaters because my eye surgery. I am looking forward to seeing the film for the first time soon. Isn’t funny how all of our favorite Brits are in this one film? RA, Martin, Cumberbatch… Thanks for the wonderful review!

  10. Great review, Marlise! And Welcome to “The Hobbit: Fan Club” I personally recommend reading the book as well as seeing the movies, as both are fantastic and seem to draw you in the amazing mind of Tolkien. The dwarves have become so familiar to me, as well as their personalities! I noticed this right from the start with their varying looks to match. Thorin; by far, is my favorite and has been so from the moment he first arrived on Bilbo’s doorstep.
    Richard as an actor, is believable and seems to blend in to every character he happens to play! You mentioned you could not detect him in the character, but I see some similarities and those eyes, I commend you for holding it together when you met him. I would faint at the sight of them (and I am married too!)
    I still think your interview was one of the greatest I’ve seen so far. Richard was so down-to-earth, completely humble and funny. Just how I imagined him to be!
    ,Anyways, back to the movie…. The scenery was stunning, where you actually felt like you were there and contrary to what the naysayers thought, I did not mind the addition of Tauriel at all. I think she did a great job. I only wish I had some of her bad-ass knife wielding skills!
    I thought the flow of the movie was good too. I didn’t mind the spiders (that’s where Sheloeb-The spider from LOTR’s is from) Thank God for Fast Forward, right?. I;on the other hand,cringe at the sight of that webby stuff. Talk about claustrophobi!. I would last about 2 seconds if I had to film that scene. Blech!!!
    Other than that, my only complaint was where it stopped. I wish it just had kept going to the end of the story. The pausing between films is a horrible thing to us fans, but I know PJ will make the next installment “There and Back again” just as awesome and amazing as the last two. December, please hurry! 🙂

  11. Aspen says:

    Richard Armitage did such a FANTASTIC job in DoS! I look forward to seeing him in TABA!

    Blessings –

    ~ Aspen

  12. Raffaella says:

    I didn’t knew Richard Armitage before seeing the movie Lo Hobbit. He’s a British actor and he wasn’t famous here in Italy. I love him from the moment I heard his wonderful voice singing Misty mountains. I would love to win the DVDs, however this afternoon I’m going to buy one (today is the release date in Italy…) Thank you Lady Anglophile, thank you WB. Hugs

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s